17/2 Socioeconomic Orders | Socialism.pdf

Conclusion

1. Utopian ideas of all property being held in common and social equality meet the realities of human society and its established interests

2. The Marx and Engels ideas of Communism have been reduced to Socialism, Moderate Socialism and even Third Way soft Neoliberalism

3. Academics and think tanks now provide politicians with their high thoughts and slogans, while globalisation and refeudalisation continue

4. In a general retreat from Socialism, Cologne School social justice is maintained through the associated Ordoliberal Social Market Economy

AR Research and Opinion

Discussion

The vested interests of the Zoroastrian clergy and the landowners bore down on the Iranian people of the Sassanid Empire and the result was Mazdak, who has been termed ‘the first Bolshevik in history’. In secular matters he promoted a pure communism of all property held in common and the idea later resurfaced in the Communist Manifesto, the Paris Commune and the Russian Revolution 1917. Common ownership made for a good slogan, but it was impractical and quickly became Stalin’s Socialism in One Country, which meant state ownership of property and a fiat command economy under a communist party dictatorship, which lasted until the collapse of the USSR in 1991. This pattern of high thoughts and low politics was seen elsewhere with the SPD under Ebert voting for the issue of War Loan debt to finance the First World War. Later Ebert assumed the Chancellorship and played a crucial role in the stabilisation of Germany following its defeat in 1918. He positioned himself as a social democrat or moderate socialist and later became the first president under the Weimar Republic constitution. In Sweden the social democrats engineered a countercyclical fiscal policy as Keynesians before Keynes in 1932. The Second World War involved a total mobilisation of economic resources for the war effort and the necessary macroeconomic demand management was based on the Keynes ‘General Theory’ published in 1936. Post War, moderate socialism and Keynesian Revolution demand management were in the ascendant with even the centre right CDU adopting the Social Market Economy of the Freiburg cum Cologne School in Germany. The capitalist private property economy was left in place with reform and redistribution occurring through social welfare funded by progressive taxation. However, the Attlee Cabinet in the UK had an outdated Labour Party Constitution Clause 4 programme of ‘industry common ownership’ nationalisation: it was implemented and became a major drag on the post War economy. It was completely undone by the march of von Hayek Neoliberalism in the form of the Thatcher Cabinet and its successors. The alleged socialists, Blair and Schröder, notably pursued a soft Neoliberalism in their policy menus: ‘Third Way’ and ‘Neue Mitte' + 'Agenda 2010’ respectively.

AR Research and Opinion

Chronology

c 488

The Zoroastrian priest Mazdak first institutes communist anticlericalism, equality, and poverty relief in the reign of Kavadh I of Iran and was executed in a counter revolution

1789

The French Revolution promotes ‘Liberty Equality Fraternity’ ending feudalism, but Marx and Engels held ‘it only abolished feudal property in favour of bourgeois property’

1848

Marx and Engels publish Manifest der Kommunistischen Partei: the class struggle with bourgeois ownership of property replaced by common ownership by the proletariat

1869

German SPD is founded and promotes Marxist trade unions with parallel developments elsewhere on the Continent, while the UK sees the growth of moderate trade unions

1871

Paris Commune experience weakens the communist tendency and the First World War 1914 leads socialist parties to abandon internationalism and proletarian solidarity

1917

Russian Revolution produces an apparently successful revolutionary communist government and in immediately post War Europe there were sporadic attempts at revolution

1924

The failure of revolution elsewhere in Europe led to Stalin’s Socialism in One Country, while moderate socialist parties entered government briefly in Germany and the UK

1932

The Swedish Social Democratic Party Finance Minister applies a countercyclical fiscal policy pre-empting the Keynesian Revolution as was done in Japan at the same time

1945

The post War social democrat parties undertake reform and redistribution through social welfare and tax policy while leaving a capitalist private property economy in place

1997

Blair becomes PM with his ‘Third Way’ and Schröder becomes Chancellor 1998 with his ‘Neue Mitte’ and ‘Agenda 2010’ both socialists however promoting soft Neoliberalism

AR Research and Opinion

Glossary

Agenda 2010

The Neoliberal coloured Hartz Reform I – IV programme

Aims are to strengthen employment, economic reform and social cohesion as part of a knowledge based economy

Blair

Sir Antony Styled 'Tony’ 1953 – PM 1997 – 2007

'New Labour' and its 'Third Way' or a confused mix of centre right economic policy and centre left social policy

CDU/CSU

Christian Democratic/Social Union Centre right

German parties promote the Social Market Economy or Freiburg Ordoliberalism with Cologne Social Justice ethics

Ebert

Friedrich 1871 – 1925 President 1919 – 1925

Fearful of a communist revolution he co-operates with General Groener to suppress the radical Spartacists etc

Keynes

Baron John Maynard 1883 – 1946 The macroeconomist

Keynes proposes free markets would not clear unemployment in a situation of inadequate aggregate demand 1936

Macroeconomics

Key identity is (G - T) + (I - S) + (X - M) + FNI = 0

The sectoral sources and sinks of demand mean that fiscal policy (G - T) should balance employment vs inflation

Schröder

Gerhard Fritz 1944 – Chancellor 1998 – 2005

Became involved in Blair’s ‘Third Way’ or ‘Neue Mitte’ supply side economic ideas: effectively a closet neoliberal

SPD

Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands

Tending to a Grand Coalition with the CDU/CSU as Establishment mainstream vs non mainstream FDP, AfD etc

The Third Way

Anthony Giddens’s academic output for 1998

A poor Anglosphere rehashing of the Social Market Economy as the Radical Centre serving the purposes of Blair

Weimar Republic

The Constitutional Assembly met in Weimar

Between Second Reich 1871 – 1918 and Third Reich 1933 – 1945 increasing chaos leading to the Hitler disaster

AR Research and Opinion

Back to Top