23/4 Security & Defence | India.pdf
Conclusion
1. Independent India had a socialist planned economy leading to a Balance of Payments Crisis, an IMF bailout and a neoliberal liberalisation
2. Economic growth with inequality led to populism and the rightist BJP became the Party of Government with China Containment an issue
3. A ‘semi rogue’ nuclear weapons state India strongly holds that it deserves a seat at the top table given its Number Four economic ranking
4. With Japan, India is an important swing factor in the geopolitics of a co-ordinated World Island adding to the Core of China + EU + Russia
AR Research and Opinion
Discussion
At independence India was notably under developed. The Party of Government, the Congress Party, under Nehru had a strong socialist colouring, which led to a close association with the USSR and the adoption of Soviet Five Year Planning. The consequence of the resulting ‘Licence Raj’ was the 1991 Balance of Payments Crisis, an IMF bailout and a neoliberal flavoured liberalisation producing economic growth with its benefits however distributed unequally. Naturally a surge to populism occurred meaning a shift rightwards to the Hindutva BJP as the new Party of Government. The neoliberalism oriented PM Modi has nevertheless maintained the Russian connection in a counter to the China oriented Pakistan, while also responding to the US World Island Containment II strategy. Building on the India US Malabar Naval Exercises from 1992 the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, The Quad, involving Australia, India, Japan and US, has evolved to be a mini NATO with various disclaimers of any Containment Mark II of China intent being made by Australia, India and Japan from time to time, if not by the US. In Indian military affairs, there is a weak domestic Military Industrial Complex MIC given a mainly public sector armaments production: there is a reported 70% reliance on imports and a 70% reliance on Russia within that. It is a semi rogue nuclear weapons state with a policy of minimum deterrence, No First Use and being a party to the Wassenaar Arrangement dual use control regime, while objecting to the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and Nuclear Non Proliferation Treaty on their being flawed and discriminatory. Its principled position is subtly different to that of the fully rogue Israel, Pakistan and North Korea. India has become the Number Four economy in a clear historical reversion (see 15/0 + 19/0 for the Statistics Analyses) and there is the natural ambition to sit at the top table as a major power. Being a semi detached Inner Crescent World Island territory, India is an important geopolitical player and a swing factor in World Island co-ordination as is the similarly semi detached Outer Crescent Japan. The Indian purchase of the Russian Triumf S-400 system underlines the swing factor status and also incidentally the honest to goodness value for money fundamental science employed by Russia in its armaments.
AR Research and Opinion
Chronology
1947 (i) |
Independence for the subcontinent partitioned between India and Pakistan with Nehru as PM of India promoting a secular, socialist and integrated republic structure model |
1947 (ii) |
Indo Pakistan War I + II over Jammu Kashmir 1947 – 1948 + 1965, War III involving the secession of East Pakistan becoming Bangladesh 1971, War IV over Ladakh 1999 |
1955 |
Krushchev Nehru Delhi Moscow exchange visits leading to the Indian assembly production of the MIG-21: a relationship on the adoption of Soviet Five Year Planning 1951 |
1962 |
War with China over Indian asylum for the Dalai Lama, border claims friction etc: the Pakistani peace brokering attempt rebuffed by India pushes Pakistan towards China |
1971 |
Pakistani ties to China and the US pushes India towards the USSR and the Indo Soviet Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Co-operation now rewritten as Russia 1993 – 2023 |
1974 |
Pokhran I a fission bomb test and Pokhran II a fusion bomb and four fission bomb tests 1998 and Pakistan’s answering Chagai I + II a total of six fission bomb tests 1998 |
1991 |
The IMF bailout with Washington Consensus conditionalities, putting the economy on a neoliberal growth track and BJP PM Modi intensifying the neoliberalism from 2014 |
1992 |
First India US Malabar Naval Exercise: held annually with Japan regularly from 2014 and Australia occasionally with the novel geopolitical term Indo Pacific used since 2011 |
2014 |
The neoliberal Hindutva BJP conclusively becomes the Party of Government under PM Modi as confirmed by his re-election 2019: nativist protectionism is quite apparent |
2016 |
At the BRICS Summit India agrees to purchase the Russian Triumf S-400 air defence weapon system and confirms this ignoring the US CAATSA economic sanctions threat 2018 |
AR Research and Opinion
Glossary
BJP |
Bharatiya Janata Party Indian People’s Party |
Political arm of RSS originally launched 1951 as Bharatiya Jana Sangh with Hindutva nativist and rightist policies |
Congress Party |
Driving for independence under Gandhi and Nehru |
Nehru’s socialism and adoption of USSR Five Year Plans on independence mean a crippling MoF Licence Raj |
Containment I + II |
US Power Projection into the Inner Crescent |
I Spykman’s containment of the USSR, II Obama’s addition of China and both seeking World Island destabilisation |
Hindutva |
Hinduness as in Bharat India vs Islamic India |
Coined by Savakar 1923, given expression by RSS that Hinduism means a Hindu cultural cum ethnic hegemony |
Modi |
Narendra Damodardas 1950 – PM 2014 – BJP |
Associated with the RSS since age 8, Chief Minister of Gujarat, but controversial given his nativist Hindutva drive |
Nehru |
Jawaharlal 1889 – 1964 PM 1947 – 1964 |
A socially advantaged Pandit Kashmiri, he led the independence movement in liaison with Gandhi to its success in 1947 |
RSS |
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh Founded 1925 |
National Patriotic Organisation promotes Hindutva to strengthen the Hindu Community by making it fully exclusive |
Triumf S-400 |
In direct competition with the US Patriot PAC-3 |
Generally Triumf is considered superior and value for money: the Iranian attack on Saudi Arabia proved the matter |
Wassenaar |
Arrangement The old COCOM updated 1996 |
Armaments, dual use goods, technology etc export control: 42 members but Israel, Pakistan and N Korea absent |
World Island |
The territory of the Inner Crescent and Heartland |
In terms of population and GDP very much larger than the Outer Crescent making the US predominance an oddity |
AR Research and Opinion
